The Back Pages

What happened on this day in football and boxing history

← Weekend reads

Weekend read — part 2 of 3

World heavyweight title · 1974

Foreman takes Frazier's title, Norton breaks Ali's jaw, and Ali wins the rematch

In the years after their first fight, Joe Frazier lost his title to George Foreman in two rounds and Muhammad Ali lost to Ken Norton. When they met again at Madison Square Garden in January 1974, with no world title at stake, Ali won on points.

The day after Joe Frazier beat Muhammad Ali at Madison Square Garden in March 1971, the Associated Press reported that a rematch that summer at the Los Angeles Forum was "almost a certainty". It took almost three years. Frazier would not split the money evenly a second time. "No way," he said. "I'm the champ. I won. I'll go to hell before I give him half again."

On 28 June 1971 the Supreme Court overturned Ali's conviction for refusing induction, eight votes to none.

Ali on the road

A month later, on 26 July, Ali fought Jimmy Ellis at the Astrodome in Houston for the NABF heavyweight title. Ellis was his friend from Louisville and they had sparred together. Angelo Dundee trained them both, and because he also managed Ellis he worked Ellis's corner that night, with Ali's approval. Harry Wiley took his place with Ali. Bundini Brown forgot to pack Ali's fitted shorts, so Ali wore a plain white pair that were too big. He stopped Ellis in the 12th round, and Dundee went back to him afterwards.

Between November 1971 and November 1972 Ali beat Buster Mathis in Houston, Jürgen Blin in Zürich, Mac Foster in Tokyo, George Chuvalo in Vancouver, Jerry Quarry again in Las Vegas, Al "Blue" Lewis at Croke Park in Dublin, Floyd Patterson at the Garden and Bob Foster at Stateline, Nevada. On 14 February 1973 he outpointed Joe Bugner over 12 rounds in Las Vegas and said afterwards that Bugner was capable of becoming world champion.

Frazier's defences

Frazier defended his title twice in 1972. On 15 January, at the Rivergate Auditorium in New Orleans, the night before Super Bowl VI, he fought Terry Daniels, a student at Southern Methodist University. Daniels went down once in the first round, twice in the third and twice in the fourth before the referee stopped it. "Don't stop, damn it... There's nothing wrong," Daniels protested.

On 25 May he fought Ron Stander at the Civic Auditorium in Omaha, Nebraska, as a 10–1 favourite. He opened a cut on the bridge of Stander's nose in the third, and the fight was stopped after the fourth round on the ring doctor's advice.

Kingston

Yank Durham, Frazier's trainer and manager, tried to talk him out of fighting George Foreman, telling him there was nothing to gain. Frazier overruled him. They met at the National Stadium in Kingston, Jamaica, on 22 January 1973, in a fight billed as "The Sunshine Showdown". Frazier was 29–0 with 25 knockouts, Foreman, the 1968 Olympic champion, 37–0 with 34. Foreman was about four inches taller and had an eight-inch advantage in reach. Frazier was the clear favourite.

Foreman's trainer was Dick Sadler. "I told George just to think of Frazier as some old boy he beat in Mexico City," Sadler said.

Frazier was down three times in the first round, once from a left in the middle of it and the last time as the bell went. Durham had to lift him onto his stool. Three more knockdowns came in little more than a minute of the second round, the last from a right uppercut that lifted Frazier into the air and bounced him on the floor. The referee, Arthur Mercante, stopped it there, after six knockdowns inside the first five minutes. On the broadcast Howard Cosell called "Down goes Frazier!" and kept repeating it.

"I didn't want to hurt him any more," Foreman said. "I kept begging Yancey Durham to stop it." Frazier said: "I should have stayed down low and gone in close underneath, but I was too bullheaded."

San Diego

Two months later Ali lost for the second time as a professional. On 31 March 1973 he fought Ken Norton at the San Diego Sports Arena, in Norton's adopted home town, for the NABF title. Ali was a 5–1 favourite and Norton the No 6 contender. Norton's trainer was Eddie Futch.

Ali came in heavy at 221lb and had missed almost all of his final week of training with a sprained ankle. Norton broke his jaw, and Ali went the full 12 rounds with it. "Got hit with a right cross over a left jab," Ali said. Norton won a split decision. Dr Gary Manchester, who operated on the jaw, called it "a very bad break" with "three or four jagged edges".

"I didn't train properly because I really didn't think Ken was that great a fighter," Ali said. "I was wrong."

They fought again at the Forum in Inglewood on 10 September. Ali weighed 212lb and had trained at Deer Lake, Pennsylvania. Norton caught up late, and Ali won the last round with combinations. He took a split decision, and Sports Illustrated reported that the referee's vote carried it. "Ken Norton is the best man I have ever fought," Ali said. "No man could hit me as much as Norton did in the shape that I am." They would meet a third time, at Yankee Stadium in 1976.

Durham and Futch

On 2 July 1973 Frazier fought Bugner over 12 rounds at Earls Court in London. He put Bugner down with a left hook in the tenth, and Bugner got up and staggered him before the round was out. The referee, Harry Gibbs, was the only scorer, and gave it to Frazier by 59¼ to 58½.

On 30 August Yank Durham died of a stroke at Temple University Hospital. He was 52. Before the first Ali fight he had said: "We developed a style a long time ago to beat Clay, Joe has it down pat now." His place as Frazier's head trainer and manager went to Eddie Futch, who had first worked with Frazier and Durham in the 1960s, and who had been in Norton's corner in San Diego.

The studio

On 17 January 1974 Ali and Frazier appeared together on The Dick Cavett Show. They joked and threw mock punches, but the tension was obvious. Five days before the fight they went to ABC's studios in New York to go over film of the first fight with Cosell for Wide World of Sports.

The argument started over the hospital stays after the first fight. "I went to the hospital for 10 minutes," Ali said. "You went for a month." Frazier said he had been resting. "That shows how dumb you are," Ali said, and called him ignorant.

"Why do you think I'm ignorant?" Frazier asked, and stood up. Ali grabbed him, and the two of them ended up on the floor before they were separated. Ali's brother came onto the set. "I don't want anyone calling me ignorant," Frazier said, "and I'm sick of taking his abuse." Then he left the studio. The New York State Athletic Commission fined them $5,000 each.

The second fight

They met at the Garden on 28 January 1974, in a fight billed as "Super Fight II". No world title was at stake; Foreman held it. The NABF belt Ali had won back from Norton was on the line, over 12 rounds. Ali weighed 212lb and Frazier 209lb, and each was guaranteed $850,000. It was a sell-out, with a crowd of more than 20,000. The referee was Tony Perez, and Futch was in Frazier's corner.

By The Fight City's reckoning, Ali took the first four rounds. In the second he hurt Frazier with a straight right to the jaw and drove him into the ropes. Then Perez stepped between them, thinking the round was over. It was not. "Somebody called 'bell,' so I stopped them both," Perez said. "Then the gong table yelled, 'Tony, the round isn't over.' Usually I hear the bell, but the bell was defective before the fight. They had to call the electrician to fix it. It was only five to eight seconds." Frazier got a breather.

When Ali was not working, Mark Kram wrote in Sports Illustrated, "he made sure Frazier did not either, artfully tying him up time and time again". Futch's study of the film counted well over a hundred holds, many of them with Ali holding Frazier's head and pushing down on his neck. Frazier and Futch complained that Perez would not penalise it. "The only violation," Perez said, "is if you [hold] and hit at the same time."

In The Fight City's account, Frazier found his left hook in the seventh, took the eighth as well and landed more hooks in the tenth. Ali came back in the ninth, both men landed in the 11th, and Ali finished strongly in the 12th. The cards were 8–4, 7–4–1 and 6–5–1, all for Ali. Red Smith of the New York Times scored it narrowly for Frazier, and Frazier objected to the decision. Ali came out unmarked and Frazier's face was swollen. Kram called it "ring generalship over a one-man army".

"Do I look like I'm 32 years old?" Ali asked. "Did I fight like a 32-year-old?"

Towards Kinshasa

The win earned Ali his shot at Foreman. Foreman knocked out Norton in the second round in Caracas in 1974, and in June that year Frazier stopped Jerry Quarry in the fifth round at the Garden. Ali went to Zaire 44–2, both of the defeats to men he had since beaten. On 30 October 1974, in Kinshasa, he knocked Foreman out in the eighth round and was heavyweight champion again.