The Back Pages

What happened on this day in football and boxing history

← Weekend reads

Weekend read — part 1 of 3

World heavyweight title · 1971

Frazier puts Ali down in the 15th and hands him his first defeat

In March 1971 Joe Frazier, who had won the heavyweight title while Muhammad Ali was banned, met the unbeaten former champion at Madison Square Garden. A left hook in the last round put Ali on the floor and settled it.

On 8 March 1971, at Madison Square Garden in New York, two unbeaten men who held or had held the heavyweight title met for it, the first time that had happened. Joe Frazier, the WBA and WBC champion, was 26–0 with 23 knockouts. Muhammad Ali was 31–0 with 25. Both had won Olympic gold. Frazier was 27 and Ali 29, and each was guaranteed $2.5 million. It was the first of their three fights, and the last was in Manila in 1975.

The sharecroppers' son

Frazier was born in Beaufort, South Carolina, on 12 January 1944, one of a large family, and grew up in Laurel Bay. His parents, Rubin and Dolly, were sharecroppers, and he was chopping wood and picking cotton from the age of seven. "I never had a little-boy life," he said.

In 1959, at 15, after a confrontation with an employer, he left on a Greyhound bus for Philadelphia. His mother had told him: "Son, if you can't get along with the white folks, then leave home." He found work at the Cross Brothers meat-packing plant in Kensington and practised his punches on the hanging sides of beef. In late 1961 he joined the Police Athletic League gym at 22nd Street and Columbia Avenue, where he was trained by Yancey "Yank" Durham. "Go out there," Durham told him, "and make smoke come from those gloves."

He lost to Buster Mathis in the US trials for the 1964 Olympics, but Mathis was injured and Frazier went to Tokyo in his place. He broke his left thumb in the semi-final. He kept the injury quiet, fought the final with the thumb taped and won the heavyweight gold medal.

Durham helped put together Cloverlay, a group of Philadelphia businessmen who bought shares in Frazier's career at $250 each. One shareholder was Larry Merchant, later the HBO commentator. Frazier made his professional debut on 16 August 1965 and stopped Woody Goss in the first round.

The exile

Ali's last fight before he was banned was against Zora Folley on 22 March 1967. On 28 April 1967, in Houston, he refused to step forward when his name was called for the US armed forces. The same day the New York State Athletic Commission suspended his licence and he was stripped of his title.

On 20 June 1967 a federal jury in Houston took 21 minutes to convict him of violating the Selective Service laws. He was sentenced to five years in prison and fined $10,000. He stayed free on bond while he appealed, but his passport was taken.

Frazier takes the title

With Ali gone, the WBA ran an eight-man elimination tournament for the vacant title. Frazier, ranked second, declined to enter. Instead, on 4 March 1968 at the Garden, he stopped Mathis in the 11th round to win the New York State Athletic Commission's version of the championship.

The WBA tournament was won by Jimmy Ellis, who beat Jerry Quarry on a split decision in Oakland on 27 April 1968. Ellis had been Ali's sparring partner, and his trainer was Angelo Dundee. He and Frazier met at the Garden on 16 February 1970. Frazier knocked him down twice in the fourth round, and Dundee asked for it to be stopped before the fifth. Frazier now held the WBA and WBC titles.

Friends

While Ali was out of the ring, Frazier lent him money. William Nack of Sports Illustrated recorded one occasion when he gave Ali $2,000 to pay an overdue bill at the City Squire Motor Inn in New York. He also lobbied for Ali to get his licence back, including an appeal to President Richard Nixon. "He'd come to the gym and call me on the telephone... We were friends, we were great friends," Frazier said in 1996.

The way back

On 14 September 1970 Judge Walter Mansfield of the US District Court for the Southern District of New York granted an injunction stopping the commission from refusing Ali a licence because of his conviction. The court found the commission had licensed convicted applicants in "at least 244 instances", among them "some 94 felons".

His first fight back was in Atlanta on 26 October 1970, three and a half years after the Folley fight, and he stopped Jerry Quarry on cuts after three rounds. On 7 December he fought Oscar Bonavena at the Garden. Bonavena had twice gone the distance with Frazier. Ali stopped him in the 15th round, dropping him three times in it. "I have done what Joe Frazier couldn't do," Ali said, "knocked out Oscar Bonavena. Now where is he?"

Uncle Tom

The friendship did not survive the build-up. "Joe Frazier is too ugly to be champ," Ali said. "Joe Frazier is too dumb to be champ. The heavyweight champion should be smart and pretty, like me." He went further: "Ninety-eight percent of my people are for me. They identify with my struggle.... If I win, they win. I lose, they lose. Anybody black who thinks Frazier can whup me is an Uncle Tom."

On the eve of the fight, with writers in his hotel suite at the New Yorker, he said: "Frazier's no real champion. Nobody wants to talk to him. Oh, maybe Nixon. Nixon will call him if he wins. I don't think he'll call me."

Before the fight Frazier said: "Clay is good, but he isn't good enough to escape." Twenty-five years later he said: "He called me an Uncle Tom. For a guy who did as much for him as I did, that was cruel."

The fight became, in History.com's words, "a proxy battle for a divided nation", with Frazier the establishment's hero "purely by not being Ali". Dave Zirin of The Nation wrote that it was cast as "a culture war between the 'draft dodger' Ali and the 'establishment hero' Joe Frazier". Ed Schuyler Jr of the Associated Press, who covered it at ringside, said: "It went beyond boxing. It had a mixture of religion, patriotism and, of course, racism."

The Garden

Most of the fighters' $5 million came from a $4 million bank guarantee put up by Jack Kent Cooke. Ringside seats cost $150 and seats in the upper reaches $20, and the Garden sold out.

Frank Sinatra was at ringside with a camera, taking photographs for Life magazine. Burt Lancaster was a colour commentator on the closed-circuit broadcast. Diana Ross, Woody Allen, Norman Mailer and members of the Kennedy family were there, and so were the Apollo 14 astronauts, "still bearded from their trip to space". "Anybody who was anybody was there," said Ali's business manager, Gene Kilroy. "If you weren't there, you weren't anybody." The worldwide audience was estimated at 300 million.

Frazier weighed 205½lb and Ali 215lb. The referee was Arthur Mercante, who in New York also scored, and the judges were Artie Aidala and Bill Recht.

Fifteen rounds

Ali jabbed and moved early on. His jab, in the words of Mark Kram of Sports Illustrated, "probed and distributed pain and perplexed Frazier", and raised welts on his face. In the third Frazier came out smiling and beckoned Ali to come and meet him.

After the sixth Ali tired. His jab, Kram wrote, "faded like a sick flower". He hung on the ropes and spent "long and dangerous periods in the corners". In the eighth both men slowed, the crowd booed and Mercante told them to fight. After nine rounds, the Associated Press reported, it was close.

In the 11th Frazier hurt Ali with a left hook. Kram wrote that it left him "rubber-legged" and that a left to the body then sent him rolling back to a neutral corner. The ropes held him up. Ali grabbed, and wobbled his legs in mockery. Ali won the 14th and seemed to be rallying. Going into the last round all three officials had Frazier in front.

In the 15th a Frazier left hook caught Ali on the right side of the chin and put him down. It was only the third time he had been knocked down as a professional. He was up at four, took Mercante's mandatory eight count and finished the round on his feet.

The decision was unanimous. Mercante scored it eight rounds to six with one even, Aidala 9–6 and Recht 11–4. The Ring made it the Fight of the Year.

Afterwards

Frazier had a bloody nose and was badly swollen about both eyes. "I feel stronger now than when I went in," he said. "Let me go straighten my face up. I ain't this ugly." "Who's the champ?" he crowed. "Who's the champ? Who's the champ?"

The right side of Ali's jaw swelled quickly. Bundini Brown told reporters it was broken. Ali went to Flower Fifth Avenue Hospital for X-rays, which showed it was not, and when doctors suggested he stay the night, he refused. Frazier spent time in hospital in the weeks that followed with high blood pressure and kidney trouble.

The next day Ali talked to reporters from his bed at the Hotel New Yorker. "It's a good feeling to lose," he said. "The people who follow you are going to lose, too. You got to set an example of how to lose."

Hugh McIlvanney wrote: "They wanted a crucifixion, but if they think that is what they got they are bad judges of the genre." Kram went back to something Ali had said before the fight: "Everyone will remember what happened here. What I want them to remember is my art and my science." Kram ended his report: "They will remember. Though not as he intended."

The Supreme Court

Ali's appeal reached the Supreme Court as Clay v. United States. It was argued on 19 April 1971 and decided on 28 June. According to the National Constitution Center, the justices first voted 5–3 against Ali in conference, and John Marshall Harlan then changed his mind after a clerk gave him reading on Ali's religion.

The final vote was 8–0, with Justice Thurgood Marshall taking no part. The Appeal Board had given no reason for refusing Ali conscientious-objector status, and there was no way of telling which of the Justice Department's three grounds it had relied on, so the conviction was reversed. Asked whether he would seek damages for the years he had been out, Ali said: "No. They only did what they thought was right at the time. I did what I thought was right. That was all." After the ruling a reporter began a question with "Champ", and Ali cut him off. "Don't call me the champ," he said. "Joe's the champ now."

Frazier was still the champion. He held the title until January 1973, when he lost it to George Foreman in Kingston.