The Back Pages

What happened on this day in football and boxing history

Back to today’s edition →

Premier League · 2009

Darren Bent's shot hits a beach ball and beats Liverpool

Five minutes into Sunderland against Liverpool, Darren Bent's shot struck a Liverpool beach ball and went past Pepe Reina. The goal should not have stood. It won the game.

During the warm-up at the Stadium of Light on 17 October 2009, beach balls were kicked into the crowd. One of them, carrying the Liverpool crest, was thrown on to the pitch by a Liverpool supporter.

In the fifth minute Andy Reid found Darren Bent on the right. Bent hit his shot from about 14 yards. About six yards out it struck the beach ball, changed direction and went past Pepe Reina.

"I didn't connect with it that well but I knew it was going on target," Bent said years later. "Then it hit the beach ball and went in! But I didn't think anything of it." Reina, he remembered, was shouting: "It hit the ball! It hit the ball!"

What the law said

Reina was right to complain. Under the Laws of the Game, a ball that touches an outside object on its way in cannot count. Mike Jones, the referee, should have disallowed the goal and restarted with a dropped ball. He gave it.

Bent said later that at half-time Jones asked him whether the shot had come off the beach ball, and seemed to panic when he was told that it had. It was the only goal of the game.

Steve Bruce, Sunderland's manager, said: "I thought it was a deflection off a player. It's got Liverpool crests all over it." He also said: "If you really know that rule then you are a little bit sad."

Rafael Benítez, who exchanged words with Bruce over the added time, did not hide behind it. "It's a bad situation for us that the ball was in the middle and was influential," he said, "but again I will say we didn't play well."

Afterwards

The Premier League said the game would not be replayed. Jones, criticised by former referees including Graham Poll and Dermot Gallagher, was demoted to the Championship the following week. Sunderland went above Liverpool in the table.

Jamie Carragher, ten years on, still could not quite believe it. "I never lost a game of football in stranger circumstances," he said. "I mean, what the hell was it even doing there?"

The beach ball survived. A Sunderland supporter bought it and gave it to the National Football Museum in Manchester, where it sits in the section on the laws of the game. Bent has made his peace with it: "It's a weird bit of history that I'm proud to be a part of."

More from this day