Weekend read — part 2 of 2
Division 1 · 1993
The Valenciennes bribe that brought down Tapie's Marseille
The day before Marseille played at Valenciennes in May 1993, three home players were offered money to let the match go. Jacques Glassmann refused and told his coach at half-time, and in 1997 Bernard Tapie went to prison.
On Wednesday 26 May 1993 Marseille beat Milan in Munich to win the Champions League. Six days earlier, on Thursday 20 May, they had played a Division 1 match at the Stade Nungesser in Valenciennes and won 1–0, with a goal from Alen Bokšić in the 21st minute. The referee was Jean-Marie Véniel.
The win kept Marseille top. With two rounds left they were a point ahead of Paris Saint-Germain, and the title was settled on 29 May, three days after Munich, when they beat PSG 3–1. On the pitch they finished with 53 points, two ahead of PSG and Monaco. Valenciennes finished 18th and went down after losing a play-off to Cannes.
For Marseille, the game was about Munich: they wanted their players fresh and uninjured for Milan.
The approach
Three Valenciennes players were approached: Jacques Glassmann, Jorge Burruchaga and Christophe Robert. Burruchaga had scored the winning goal for Argentina in the 1986 World Cup final, against West Germany, and had played at Nantes from 1985 to 1992. He and Robert were former team-mates of Jean-Jacques Eydelie, a Marseille midfielder, and Eydelie was the go-between, acting on behalf of the Marseille board.
Glassmann's version, given in 2003, is that on 19 May Robert took him aside and told him Marseille had to win. "Ils veulent qu'on laisse filer le match," Robert told him, by Glassmann's account: they want us to let the match go. Glassmann then spoke on the phone to Jean-Pierre Bernès, Marseille's general manager. As Glassmann remembered it, Bernès said: "So, would you rather lose with money in your pocket or lose with nothing? You've got no chance."
Glassmann refused. Burruchaga said later that he agreed and then changed his mind. In the car park of the Novotel, an envelope containing 250,000 francs was handed over, and Robert's wife collected it from Eydelie.
Half-time
At half-time Glassmann told the Valenciennes coach, Boro Primorac, about the approach. In the second half he told the referee, without naming anyone, and Véniel noted it in his match report.
"This was not a normal match," Véniel said in 2023. "There was a (Valenciennes) player called Glassmann who was the only one running." He also noticed Burruchaga. "He was (normally) the first player to contest decisions. But in this game, every time I made a decision against Valenciennes, Burruchaga would come and calm his players, saying 'the ref is right'."
The investigation
The case went to Éric de Montgolfier, the public prosecutor at Valenciennes, and the examining magistrate Bernard Beffy. The league lodged its complaint in June, and on 8 June Burruchaga confirmed Glassmann's accusations. By late June Robert had confessed and led police to 250,000 francs buried in his aunt's garden at Ribérac, in the Dordogne. "That cash stunk so much I had to bury it," he said. Tapie's first explanation was that the money was a loan to help Robert open a restaurant.
Eydelie was arrested and spent 17 days in prison. Police searched Marseille's headquarters, and Milan's president called for the final to be annulled and replayed. On 6 July Bernès was placed under formal investigation for active corruption. On 12 July Eydelie admitted the facts, and the same day Primorac stated that Tapie had proposed he "porter le chapeau": take the blame. On 25 July Bernès resigned as general manager.
Tapie's approach to Primorac was made on 17 June. At the end of July the former minister Jacques Mellick said he had been with Tapie in Paris that day, contradicting Primorac, although an hour earlier Mellick had been at a meeting in Béthune. He was later convicted of giving false testimony.
Stripped and relegated
On 6 September 1993 UEFA threw Marseille out of the 1993–94 Champions League, so they could not defend the trophy. Monaco took France's place. Marseille were also barred from the European Super Cup, and Milan played Parma instead, a tie Parma won. They were not allowed to play in the Intercontinental Cup either, and Milan lost 3–2 to São Paulo in Tokyo on 12 December 1993. The European title itself was not taken away.
On 22 September the French federation stripped Marseille of the 1992–93 league title. It was offered to PSG, who turned it down, and it was never awarded. Eydelie, Robert and Burruchaga were suspended. Bernès was banned for life by the federation in 1994; FIFA overturned the ban in 1996, and by 1999 he was working as an agent.
Tapie was charged with complicity in corruption in February 1994 and was forced out as president that year. Pierre Cangioni replaced him. Marseille finished second in Division 1 in 1993–94, eight points behind PSG, and on 22 April 1994 they were relegated to Division 2 by administrative decision, over the scandal and the club's financial irregularities.
They won Division 2 in 1994–95 with 84 points but were not promoted because of their financial problems. The club filed for bankruptcy and spent a second season in Division 2, finishing second in 1995–96 and going up with Caen and Nancy. Robert Louis-Dreyfus, the owner of Adidas, rescued the club in 1996, and Marseille were back in Division 1 for 1996–97. Valenciennes were relegated again and did not return to the top flight until 2006–07.
The trial
The trial opened at the tribunal correctionnel in Valenciennes on 13 March 1995. Bernès and Eydelie admitted corruption and blamed Tapie. "There was indeed an attempt to bribe the Valenciennes players on my part, on Bernard Tapie's orders," Bernès said, in French. Tapie told the court: "I lied, but I did it in good faith."
In May 1995 Tapie was convicted of complicity in corruption and subornation of witnesses and sentenced to two years in prison, one of them to be served. Bernès was given a suspended sentence. Eydelie received a one-year suspended sentence, Robert and Burruchaga six months suspended and fines of 5,000 francs each, and Robert's wife, Marie-Christine, three months suspended.
At the appeal court in Douai, on 24 October 1995, Tapie admitted meeting Primorac and asking him to take the blame, but denied trying to fix the match. In November the court cut his sentence to two years with eight months to serve, and banned him from public office for three years. The players' suspended sentences were confirmed. "I think everyone can judge for themselves whether that deserves eight months in jail," Tapie said.
Tapie in prison
Tapie had been minister for city affairs from April to May 1992 and again from December 1992 to March 1993, and he was a member of the National Assembly for Bouches-du-Rhône. In 1994 he was elected to the European Parliament on the Énergie radicale list, which took 12.03 per cent. By 1995 he was personally bankrupt.
He arrived at La Santé prison in Paris on 3 February 1997. "He's not too happy," said his lawyer, Jean-Yves Liénard. "He feels like he doesn't really deserve it, but he wants to pursue his appeal. It's not a vacation resort. It's grey. It's cold. It's isolation in an unknown world." Tapie was moved to Luynes, then to the Baumettes on day release, and was out in July after more than five months.
"If the president of OM hadn't been Bernard Tapie, he would never have gone to prison," de Montgolfier said, in French, in 2009. "The facts didn't merit it."
Glassmann
Glassmann's contract at Valenciennes was not renewed. He was called "la balance", the informer, and was whistled at many grounds and given police protection; for one match, against Nice, his club left him out to avoid trouble with supporters. He went seven months without pay, "sept mois affreux, sans toucher le moindre centime" (seven awful months without earning a penny). He played amateur football at Maubeuge and then, from 1995 to 1998, at Sainte-Rose on Réunion. "Careful: don't think it was exile," he said in 2003. "I chose to leave."
In 1995 FIFA gave him its Fair Play Award, for his "courageous attitude as whistleblower in the Valenciennes and Marseille bribery case".
"Ever since I exposed the attempted bribery run by Bernard Tapie, there's always some crank to insult me, in the street, at the cinema," he said in 2003, in French.
Tapie died of cancer in Paris on 3 October 2021, aged 78. Marseille are still the 1993 European champions. The French title for 1992–93 has never been awarded.