The Back Pages

What happened on this day in football and boxing history

Back to today’s edition →

World heavyweight title · 1999

Lewis beats Holyfield at the second attempt and holds every belt

Eight months after a draw few people accepted, Lennox Lewis outpointed Evander Holyfield in Las Vegas to become undisputed heavyweight champion. This verdict was argued over too.

The first fight, at Madison Square Garden on 13 March 1999, was scored a split draw: 116–113 to Lewis, 115–113 to Holyfield and 115–115. It was widely seen as one of the worst verdicts in boxing, and many believed Lewis had won. The sanctioning bodies ordered a rematch.

It came on 13 November at the Thomas & Mack Center in Las Vegas, with Lewis's WBC belt, Holyfield's WBA and IBF belts and the vacant IBO title at stake. Holyfield's record was 36-3-1 and Lewis's 34-1-1. Lewis was 34 and weighed 242 lb; Holyfield was 37 and weighed 217 lb. Each was guaranteed $15 million. A crowd of 17,078 paid $16.86 million, then the biggest gate in boxing history. Mitch Halpern was the referee.

Twelve rounds

Lewis won the first two rounds. A clash of heads in the fifth cut his forehead, and Holyfield took the middle of the fight, the fourth to the seventh, stunning Lewis in the seventh. Lewis won the eighth to the 11th. Nobody was knocked down.

Lewis landed more. Compubox counted 195 of his 490 punches landing, against 137 of Holyfield's 416. "I fought intelligently because Holyfield is known for faking being hurt," Lewis said, looking back.

All three judges scored it for him: Jerry Roth 115–113, Chuck Giampa 116–112 and Bill Graham 117–111.

The verdict

"It don't get any bigger than this," Lewis said. "Now I'll go down in the history books forever." He was the first undisputed heavyweight champion since Riddick Bowe beat Holyfield seven years earlier to the day, and the first British one since Bob Fitzsimmons in the 1890s.

Not everyone agreed with the cards. HBO's Harold Lederman had Lewis winning 116–112, but the New York Post and ESPN had Holyfield ahead by the same score. "When a draw would have been a fair result, Lewis got the nod," said Mike Costello of BBC Sport. Holyfield said: "I thought this was closer than the first fight." Lewis's own trainer, Emanuel Steward, said: "That was no superstar performance."

Lewis did not hold everything for long. The WBA stripped him when he chose to fight Michael Grant rather than its mandatory challenger, John Ruiz. Lewis knocked Grant out in two rounds.

Nobody fought for the undisputed heavyweight title again until Oleksandr Usyk beat Tyson Fury on 18 May 2024.

More from this day