World welterweight title · 2007
Cotto survives Mosley's ninth and keeps his title
Miguel Cotto was unbeaten and Shane Mosley was 36. At Madison Square Garden they landed exactly the same number of punches, and Cotto got the decision.
Miguel Cotto had won the vacant WBA welterweight title in December 2006 by stopping Carlos Quintana, and in June 2007 he had stopped Zab Judah. He was 27 and had never lost. Shane Mosley was 36 and had won five in a row. The fight had been kept apart by the feud between their promoters, Top Rank and Golden Boy. When the two companies settled, it was made for Madison Square Garden on 10 November 2007.
For all his years at the top, it was Mosley's first fight at the Garden. The crowd was 15,251.
The ninth
Mosley shook Cotto with a right hand in the fifth, and rocked him again in the seventh.
In the ninth Mosley landed a left hook that hurt Cotto. Bad Left Hook's reporter wrote that Cotto "was backing down from Shane Mosley, which I have rarely seen". Cotto went back to his corner hurt.
"He punches real hard," Cotto said afterwards. "I was hurt."
In the tenth the referee, Benjy Esteves Jr, stopped the action so that the canvas could be dried. The same reporter called it a questionable move that broke Mosley's momentum. In the last round Mosley chased and Cotto kept away from him. In the final minute an accidental clash of heads cut Cotto.
The cards
Each man landed 248 punches. Two judges scored it 115–113 for Cotto and the third had him a little further ahead. The Associated Press had it level at 114–114.
"I thought I had a big lead," Cotto said. "We both did our best, we both gave it our all. Mosley hit me with some real hard punches."
Mosley did not argue. "Miguel was very strong, not only was he a powerful puncher but he can box," he said. "He mixed it up and did a hell of a good job. He's a young lion on the way to greatness."
Cotto stayed unbeaten for eight more months. In July 2008 he lost for the first time, stopped by Antonio Margarito in the 11th round, a result later clouded by Margarito's attempted use of illegal hand wraps in a later fight.